Today I am so pleased to welcome my brother, David, as my Guest Blogger. He shares with us a piece he wrote entitled Jesus Evicted: A Short Advent Story.
Jesus Evicted: A Short Advent Story
by David Guretzki
While they were there, the time came for the baby
to be born, and she gave birth to her firstborn, a son. She wrapped him
in cloths and placed him in a manger, because there was no room for them
in the inn. (Luke 2:6-7)
It was the usual row which came up year after year on town council
for the past 10 years straight: Could the crèche be located on the lawn
of City Hall or not?
Lines were drawn, as usual, between the “pro” and “con” crowds.
Prominent on one side was cranky old Bartholomew (“Bart”) Collins, a
part-time Social Studies substitute teacher for Bethel High, who
faithfully reminded everyone on council of the principled need to keep
“church and state” separated. His position was clear: City Hall is no
place for Baby Jesus! On the other side was Miriam Dominique (or as more
commonly known, Sister Mary), well known as the town’s longest-employed
and most beloved kindergarten teacher at St. Peter’s Elementary. Not
surprisingly, Sister Mary argued consistently and vociferously to “keep
Christ in Christmas”!
Every year for the past decade, Sister Mary’s sensible voice had
prevailed, and every year for the past decade, Baby Jesus lay quietly,
but prominently, on City Hall lawn. But every year the vote edged closer
and closer toward a “secular upset.” Two years ago, the usual 8 to 1
vote had been 6 to 3, and last year, Jesus had only narrowly avoided
being ousted with a 5 to 4 vote.
Given this history, the city’s council chamber this year was buzzing
with both nervous and gleeful energy. Whether one was nervous or
gleeful, depended on which side of the hall one sat: Sister Mary’s
“Bible thumpers” occupied stage left and nervously fidgeted and frowned
across the aisle toward Bart’s fellow “commies” clustered in strategic
spots on the right. But tonight, the Bart-contingent was poised for a
well deserved victory. Victory indeed! For rumour had it that Bart had
successfully swayed the new-comer and youngest member of council , one
Lisbeth Johnson, to the cause. But only time–and a fateful vote–would
“I now moo-ve to the last item of bizness,” the Chair drawled. “We
have here a motion on the floor from thuh last meetin’ which reads,
“Moved by Councillor Dominique that a Nativity scene be located on the
East Lawn of City Hall for the full month of December to commemorate the
As was the custom, various members of council rose, one by one, to
speak for or against the motion. The speeches were short and to the
point, and civic respect marked both sides of the debate. By now,
virtually everyone in the room knew Bart and Mary’s speeches–neither had
bothered to change a word in their argument from year to year.
Consequently, few really listened to their arguments while they spoke,
including the town reporter who momentarily suspended her scribbling to
sip her Starbucks and send an SMS message.
Beyond Bart and Mary, everybody else’s position also became clear:
three Councillors each supported Bart and Mary, leaving only one more to
speak–the newcomer. Now, the commonplace gave way to suspense, as if
there were an invisible scoreboard showing a 4 to 4 tied hockey game!
Onlookers sat on the edge of their seats, waiting for sudden death
overtime to decide the game!
And then, Lisbeth rose to her feet to speak.
Mary looked down with despondency. Word on the street was that the
newcomer would come in like an clumsy ox and upset the manger. Sister
Mary prayed silently that the onslaught of evil forces pervading the
room would be vanquished by the heavenly host, while Bart’s countenance
shone brighter than the star in the East as he already sensed victory!
“Most of you are still getting to know me,” young Lisbeth began. “So
let me tell you just a bit about myself before I argue for or against
“I was raised in a little town, not too far from here, where every
Sunday I attended a little white church with my parents. There I heard
weekly the stories of the Bible. Of course, you won’t be surprised that I
heard the story about Jesus, Mary and Joseph, the angels, the shepherds
and the wisemen over and over again. And to be honest, I loved that
story and I still love it today. In fact, the Christmas story really
gives me a warm feeling inside whenever I hear it. And whenever I see a
Nativity scene, I get that same feeling all over again.”
Sister Mary raised her head, pondering these words. Perhaps all was not lost. Perhaps Lisbeth would rise up and support the Christ Child!
Bart, on the hand, nervously nudged his pen back and forth on the
desk. Was Lisbeth going to cave in to emotion and nostalgia over against
clear-headed rationality and civic principles? Would she give in to the
self-righteous duress imposed by those–those–fundamentalists?
Lisbeth continued. “But today, the decision to put a crèche on the
lawn of City Hall cannot be decided by memories of days gone past or of
personal nostalgia, even my own. Rather, we must decide on the basis of
what really is for the good of all us citizens, whether
Christian or not. And those of you here today who claim to be
Christians, I don’t think I need to remind you that Christmas story
itself says something about having ‘peace on earth and good will amongst
all the people’.”
Lisbeth paused. Those in attendance held their breath. The clock ticked more slowly than it ought to have.
“I realize that my vote on this issue will likely be a tie-breaker,
and that whatever I vote, I will likely be vilified by the other side.
“But today, let it be known here and now that I will vote against my own warm feelings, and therefore, I will vote against the
motion to allow the crèche on City Hall Lawn. Not everyone in this town
is a Christian and since City Hall is a public space, I declare my
conviction that the Nativity does not belong there.” And with this,
Lisbeth sat confidently down.
The room was, momentarily, silent, only to erupt a full 3.5 seconds
later with a grand cheer from the right when Lisbeth’s intended vote
sank in! Bart and company had finally won! Council had finally seen the
light. Time to send Jesus packing!
On the left, Mary’s supporters were sullen. A few even sobbed
quietly. Moments later, when the chair called for the vote, the crèche,
for the first time in a decade, was prohibited from occupying public
space. 5 to 4 against the motion. The motion was defeated!
The next morning, a busy businessman, having finished his morning
newspaper, latte and cigarette, stuffed paper, cup and butt into the
garbage can on the corner.
Emerging from the alley, a frail, straggly-haired, old man, reeking
of urine, shuffled toward the receptacle, grabbed the paper, snatched
the cup and rescued the smoldering cigarette. Pausing momentarily, he
scanned the paper’s front headline: “Baby Jesus Evicted!
“I know the feelin’,” he muttered as he stuffed the newspaper into
his jacket, if only to battle the bitter cold yet one more day.
Previously posted at Theommetary December 14, 2010
David Guretzki teaches theology at Briercrest College & Seminary (Caronport, Saskatchewan, Canada). He's married and has three children. He enjoys reading, star gazing, and ham radios ... (and being Brenda's 'little' brother ... hehe ... he doesn't know I added that part).